Press Release: 7 August 2021
In a most shocking development, officials of the Bangalore Development Authority, backed by Bangalore Police, destroyed about 10 houses of villagers of Doddabettahalli. Each and every one of the families affected were from Dalit communities. In a similar drive, about 22 houses had been demolished at Somashettahalli, Meda Agrahara and Lakshmipura villages of the same region a few days ago, which resulted in widespread protests. A video recording of the devastation and the most painful account of those affected can be seen here:
Villagers from 17 villages affected by the under development Shivarama Karanth Layout have been strongly contesting and protesting against these demolitions, particularly on grounds that the houses of Dalit families, farmers and pastoralists are being targeted. They have made desperate efforts to approach every authority to raise their grievance: that they have been residents of this land for hundreds of years and have lived off the land practising farming and pastoralism. Those without farmland have lived in small pockets of land they owned working on farms and as labourers. They have no other source of livelihood.
When BDA proposed to acquire these lands with a preliminary notification as per the BDA Act on 31 December 2008, families filed their objections as per the due process of law. Thereafter, the Government dithered on the acquisition, even denotifying 750 acres of the proposed acquisition. As the Notification was not given effect for five years, the Karnataka High Court even set aside the preliminary notification.
Meanwhile, various statutory authorities allowed dozens of families to build their houses, including in private layouts, and even extended them ‘No Objection Certificates’, besides providing water and electricity connections as well. The BDA, which had not taken any action to pursue its 2008 effort, resumed acquisition proceedings for the Shivaram Karanth Layout in 2014. The matter was challenged in court and eventually reached the Supreme Court, which on 3rd August 2018 ruled in favour of the acquisition proceedings subject to the direction that no legal dwelling would be destroyed and those losing land would be compensated as per the approved package. To ensure that there was no injustice in displacement and dislocation, a 3-member committee was constituted under retired High Court Judge Justice A.V. Chandrashekar, and including former BDA Commissioner Mr. Jayakar Jerome and former Karnataka Director General of Police, Mr. S. T. Ramesh as members.
Dalit families targeted in demolitions:
Early this morning, Jayamma was setting up the cooking pot to make breakfast in her little dwelling in Doddabettahalli, when police barged in and asked her to get out. When she enquired why, they slapped her, dragged her out, beat her (injuring her in the leg), and destroyed her house. For a woman who struggled and built her house doing coolie work, and whose son is recovering from injuries suffered in a serious road accident, the trauma was unbearable. She fainted. The police took her to a hospital several kilometres away, but instead of getting her treated, simply abandoned her unattended outside the hospital. Pointing to her meagre belongings and food now thrown into the open, Jayamma asked where is she to go, and where is she to sleep, as rains are pounding the area.
An inconsolable Sharadamma asked what crime she had committed in living in her dwelling, built in a small plot of land that had come to her down the generations, which too was ruthlessly destroyed this morning. She broke down narrating how her son, who pleaded with the police to not destroy their tiny dwelling, was dragged into the police van and arrested on false charges of obstructing the massive police force.
Ramesh of Dalit Sangarsh Samithi, Mavallipura informed the gathering that women, men and even children who resisted the demolition of their houses have been arrested on grounds of obstruction of official duties. He asserted that no official of the BDA had ever come to any of the dwellings, but these families are now under the threat of inhumane displacement. He wondered why only Dalit families had been targeted while dozes of houses, several of which have been built in the past year or two, remained untouched. He asked woefully: is the Constitution speaking only for the protection of upper castes and the privileged? Despite Dr. B R Ambedkar’s earnest efforts, are Dalit women and children to live off the streets and toil in the houses of the rich and middle classes?
Basavaraj Padayatri, whose wife was the President of the local village Panchayat, was devastated that Dalit families were exclusively targeted for displacement and dislocation, without application of due process. He wondered if the newly appointed Hon’ble Chief Minister of Karnataka Basavaraj Bommai, who is also the Minister of Bangalore Development, considers this inhumane displacement and destruction of humble dwellings of Dalit and poor families to be the ‘achhe din’ promised by the Hon’ble Prime Minister Narendra Modi. Pointing to a cow that had fallen into a well due to the confusion that prevailed as houses and cowsheds were being destroyed, he demanded answers from the Union Government: was this how it intended to protect ‘holy’ cows?
No relief. No rehabilitation. Gross Injustice
As the monsoon rains pound the area, dozens of families who have lived in villages here for generations have nowhere to go. They painfully narrated that no public official from any department has reached out to them with relief yet. There has been absolutely no effort whatsoever from any of these agencies to address their grievances, or to consider their just rehabilitation based on the Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013 (“Land Acquisition Act 2013”), following the Principles of Due, Prior and Informed Consent.
Several say how they have been devastated by COVID and the associated lockdowns without any plan for them. During the lockdowns, almost all of them had no access to information, and had no idea at all that BDA officials were planning to so brutally displace them in the middle of the monsoon season, and without any compensation. Several had no idea that there were kiosks set up to assist them, as they were out early in search of work to recover from the economic devastation they have suffered from the COVID lockdowns.
Ramesh pointed out that the predominantly Dalit villages who are now threatened with displacement are the very same ones who have for nearly two decades suffered from dumping of Bangalore’s waste in Mavallipura’s illegal landfills. Dozens of families have suffered from the toxic waste which has claimed over 50 lives already. Yet, despite directions from the Hon’ble High Court of Karnataka to clean up the landfills and support families adversely affected by waste dumping, in response to PIL initiatives by Environment Support Group and Dalit Sangarsh Samithi, no action has followed from the Government. Now, the same government is throwing these communities into the streets in the most brutal manner, and that too in the Diamond Jubilee of India’s independence from colonial rule.
The impacted communities have resolved to struggle in the open demanding their human rights are fully protected, the officials guilty of selectively targeting Dalit families are booked under the SC/ST Atrocities Act, and appropriate rehabilitation measures are undertaken as per the Land Acquisition Act 2013, so that there is some hope that justice and fairness can also be enjoyed by Dalits in India. They urge the Justice A V Chandrashekar Committee to immediately visit the impacted area and take note of the inhumane attack on Dalit families and the destruction of their last hope of life.
Issued by Dalitha Sangarsh Samithi (Mavallipura) and Environment Support Group (Bangalore)
Dalitha Sangharsha Samithi
Mavallipura, Shivakote Post,
Hesaraghatta Hobli, Bangalore North Taluk.
Environment Support Group
1572, 36th Cross, 100 Feet Ring Road,
Banashankari II Stage,
Bangalore 560070. INDIA
Tel: 91-80-26713559-3561 Voice/Fax: 91-80-26713316
Email: email@example.com Web: www.esgindia.org
For further information, please contact:
M. Ramesh (DSS): 9740152184
Sana Huque (ESG): 9869941967 Email: firstname.lastname@example.org
Karthik Anjanappa (ESG): 8310569381 Email: email@example.com
Eswarappa Madhudappa (ESG): 9845448287 Email: firstname.lastname@example.org